Ikibanza c'Ubushakashatsi kuri Ruleti · Ikibanza c'Ubushakashatsi · Ibiharuro · iminota 8

Insiguro y'Ibiharuro

“Bihambaye” bisigura ko bitoshoboka cane ku ruziga rutabogamye, si “ivy'ukuri” kandi si “ivyunguka”.

Inyishu ngufi

p-value ya 0,05 isigura ko uruziga rutabogamye rworema ishusho iteye kuri ubwo buryo incuro imwe mu mirongo ibiri. Iyo urabye inziga mirongo ibiri, rumwe ruzorenga igeragezwa ku mpanuka.

akamenyero
p < 0,05
urugero rw'ivyemezo vy'ikinyoma
5% kuri buri geragezwa
umuti
gusubiramwo
ico atari co
p(uruziga rurabogamye)

p-value ico ari co

Assuming the stated null model, the p-valueubushakashatsip-valueUgushoboka kwo kubona itandukaniro rinini nk'iryabonetse canke rirengeye, iyo uruziga rutoba rubogamye.Soma vyose → is the probabilityimibareUgushobokaUgushoboka kw'ivyavuyemwo, kuva kuri 0 gushika kuri 1 canke 0% gushika 100%. Inomero imwe: 1/37 = 2,70%.Soma vyose → of a test statistic at least as extreme as the observed one. It is not the probability that the wheel is fair or that the result arose by chance. Interpretation also depends on the design, assumptions and tests attempted.

ivyavuzweni vyo?
p = 0,03 bisigura ko uruziga rutabogamye rutanga amakuru akabije nk'aya mu 3% vy'igiheego
p = 0,03 bisigura ko hari ugushoboka kwa 97% ko uruziga rubogamyeoya
p = 0,03 bisigura ko akazu gashushe kazoguma gashusheoya
p = 0,03 inyuma yo gusuzuma inziga 30 ni icemezo gikomeyeoya; witeze ivyavuyemwo nk'ivyo kimwe canke bibiri ku mpanuka
p = 0,03 kabiri, ku bitegererezo bibiri vyigenga vy'uruziga rumweubu bikwiye kwitwararikwa

Ukugereranya kwinshi

Igeragezwa ryose ukora ku ruziga rutabogamye rifise ugushoboka kwa 5% ko kurenga ku rugero rwa 5%. Gerageza inziga mirongo ibiri, rumwe ruzorenga. Gerageza uruziga rumwe mu bihe mirongo ibiri bitandukanye, kimwe kizorenga. Gerageza icitegererezo kimwe ukoresheje ingene 37 zo kugabura utuzuibikoreshoAkazuKimwe mu bibanza 37 bifise inomero kuri rotor. Kandi bita: slot, cup.Soma vyose →, ingene zitandatu zo kugabura ibice vy'uruzigauruzigaIgice c'uruzigaUrukurikirane rw'utuzu dufatanye ku ruziga, rutandukanye n'umugwi w'inomero ku kibaho c'amatego.Soma vyose → n'ingene zitatu zo kugabura amabara, hari ikizorenga. Umuti ni ugufata ingingo y'igeragezwa imbere yo kuraba amakuru, ukarikora rimwe, ukavyemeza ku makuru mashasha. Ugusuzuma kuronka uruziga “rubogamye” kenshi ni kwo nyene kwazanye ivyo vyavuyemwo.

Ugushoboka kw'icemezo c'ikinyoma nibura kimwe kuri p < 0,05%
igeragezwa 1
5%
amageragezwa 5
22,6%
amageragezwa 10
40,1%
amageragezwa 20
64,2%
amageragezwa 37 (rimwe kuri buri kazu)
85,0%
%
042,5085,0%
1 − 0,95ⁿ. Kugerageza akazu kamwe kamwe ukwako hafi ni ukwemeza ko uzoronka akazu “gahambaye”.

Ukuba bihambaye n'urugero

A large sample can detect a small departure from fairness that still does not make a bet profitable. At a true pocket probability of 1/36.5, a 35:1 bet has negative expectation. At 1/36 it breaks even. A p-value does not measure the size or practical value of an effect.

Inguvu z'igeragezwa

Power is the chance of rejecting the null under a specified alternative. For one pocket chosen in advance, an exact one-sided 5% binomial test on 1,000 spins rejects at 37 or more hits. If the true rate is 1/30, its power is about 28%, not 50%.

Urugero rukoreshwa mu ngiro

Kugira ngo ivyavuzwe vy'ukubogama bishimishe: igeragezwa ryatowe imbere, p < 0,01 aho kuba 0,05, ugusubiramwo ku citegererezo cigenga kingana n'ica mbere, n'urugero rugereranijwe utuzu dushigikiwe dufatwa rwa 1/34 canke kurenza inyuma yo gusubiramwo. Urwo rugero rwarashitsweko incuro nkeyi mu kahise k'uyu mukino kandi nta na rimwe, nk'uko inyandiko zishikirwa n'abantu bose zibigaragaza, ku ruziga rwa none rubungabunzwe.

Ibibazo

Kubera iki 0,05?

Ni akamenyero kuva mu myaka ya 1920. Nta kidasanzwe gifise; 0,01 ni urugero rwumvikana kurushiriza iyo urimwo urasuzuma inziga nyinshi.

Iyo p ari ntoyi cane, uruziga rurabogamye vy'ukuri?

Birashoboka ko rudatanga ivyavuyemwo bingana. Vyoshobora kuba ingaruka ya croupier, ikosa ryo kwandika canke ikibazo co kwinjiza amakuru. Subiramwo.

Ivyavuyemwo bihambaye birambwira akazu ko gutegako?

No. That requires a separate estimate of hit probability, its uncertainty and the actual payoutamaheraIrihaIvyo itego ritsinze rizana, bivugwa nka “X kuri 1” hiyongereyeko amahera y'itego asubizwa.Soma vyose →.

Twinezwe n'Imibare

Banza ubigerageze wewe nyene. Inyishu yose irapfutse; yugurure igihe witeguye.

  1. Suppose a dozenitegoUmurwi1–12, 13–24 canke 25–36, riha 2:1.Soma vyose → chosen before data collection appears 742 times in 3,000 independent double-zerouruzigaZeruAkazu kamwe k'icatsi kibisi kadapfukwa n'itego rya rimwe kuri rimwe, ry'umurwi canke ry'inkingi; ni yo soko y'inyungu ya kazino. Kandi bita: zeru imwe, 0.Soma vyose → spins. Under the uniform model, how many standard deviationsimibareItandukaniro risanzweUmuzi kare w'ihindagurika ry'ivyavuyemwo; intera isanzwe iri hagati y'ivyavuyemwo n'agaciro kitezwe.Soma vyose → below the mean is that? What is the probabilityimibareUgushobokaUgushoboka kw'ivyavuyemwo, kuva kuri 0 gushika kuri 1 canke 0% gushika 100%. Inomero imwe: 1/37 = 2,70%.Soma vyose → of 742 or fewer hits?

    Erekana inyishu

    Inyishu Nka matandukaniro asanzwe 8,1 munsi. Uruziga rutabogamye rwobikora nka rimwe mu kugerageza 3 × 10¹⁵, ni ukuvuga nta na rimwe. Inyishu yasohowe hamwe n'ikibazo ivuga 11,75; twebwe turonka 8,07.

    Under the stated model, X is binomial with n = 3,000 and p = 12/38. Its mean is np ≈ 947.37 and its standard deviation is √(np(1 − p)) ≈ 25.46.

    The standardized difference is (742 − 947.37)/25.46 ≈ −8.07. Summing the exact binomial probabilities from 0 through 742 gives P(X ≤ 742) ≈ 9.77 × 10⁻¹⁷. A normal approximation with continuity correction gives about 4.25 × 10⁻¹⁶; the relative error is large this far into the tail.

    This is the probability of the specified data event under the model, not the probability that the wheel is fair. Such a result calls for checking the observations, independence, uniformity and analysis plan. Selecting the worst-looking dozen after inspecting data, or searching many wheels or time periods, requires accounting for that selection.

Agakuru ko gutwenga

Uruziga rumwe mu mirongo ibiri rutabogamye ruba “ruhambaye”. Ico ni co ico gitigiri gisigura.

Uruziga rumwe mu mirongo ibiri rutabogamye ruba “ruhambaye”. Ico ni co ico gitigiri gisigura.

Aho Twakuye

  1. Pearson, K. “On the criterion that a given system of deviations from the probable…” https://www.amstat.org/asa/files/pdfs/P-ValueStatement.pdf
  2. Feller, W. An Introduction to Probability Theory and Its Applications, Vol. 1. https://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/software/dataplot/refman1/auxillar/chsqgood.htm
icitegererezo: ruleti y'i Buraya, zeru imweuburyo dukoresha ↗amasoko ↗